« Putting a stake in the ground | Main | Fun or Funny »

August 22, 2005 3:15 PM

Lost in translation

I love playing around with Google Translate – mostly to look at web sites or read blogs that are written in other languages.  I’m also a big cycling fan and after this year’s Tour I decided to write to the German cyclist Jan Ullrich – one of my favorite riders and the third place finisher in this year’s contest.  I wrote my note in English but also translated it into German using Google. I had forgotten about this note until a few days ago when I actually received a note back from Jan (I’m actually pretty sure it was really from him – it certainly made my day!).  I translated it back to English also using Google, but decided that it was too important to leave to chance, so I forwarded it to a German friend of mine in Frankfurt for a second opinion.  Turns out Google did a pretty nice job translating his response, but was apparently too literal in translating my original note.  I found it pretty amusing and thought I would repeat it here – a good lesson in lexical vs. conceptual meaning.

My original note was meant to say:

Jan - You are a wonderful bicycle rider.  I've enjoyed watching you in this year's tour (as every year).  You are a great champion.  Know that you have many american fans!

(translated with Google translate - sorry if the translation is rough).

Your faithful fan,

Turns out I actually wrote:

Jan, you are a wonderful bicycle co-rider. I enjoyed being careful for you during this years Tour (as in previous years).  You are a big champion.  Did you know that you have many American ceiling-fans!

(translated with Google translate you – sad, if translate is coarse)

Your reliable ceiling-fan!


Apparently I’m Jan’s only talking ceiling fan <g>

(In case you were wondering, Jan’s response to me was: Thank you very much for your support!  You are helping me a lot! Sorry I am only replying to your letter now.  Best Regards, Jan)

Posted in: Life

COMMENTS (2)

What a Feeling.. Dancing On the Ceiling:-)
(Lionel Richie)
http://www.lyricsdepot.com/Lionel-Richie/dancing-on-the-ceiling.html

Zoli Erdos , August 23, 2005 2:21 PM

Speaking off Google!

The NY TIMES did an article on the new evil empire today. (MS is now one of the good guys.)

Here are some thoughts on Google from an entrepreneur's perspective http://smartstartup.typepad.com/my_weblog/2005/08/google_and_the_.html

Peter , August 24, 2005 12:05 PM




Remember Me?

(you may use HTML tags for style)